So I have been watching the new syndicated daytime talk shows most every day so you won't have to, because that's just the kind of selfless critic I am. I watch. You ignore. Yeah, it's all about giving back for me. But for the most part this represents cruel and unusual punishment for those viewers nationwide who do display the courage to tune in and sample the goods. If this keeps up, the ACLU is bound to step in and put a halt to the civil liberties violations being perpetrated daily on audience members who happen to suffer from a slow trigger-finger on the remote.
My humble assessment so far:
RACHAEL RAY -- She isn't a talk show host so much as a human espresso maker who CAN'T STOP MOVING and REFUSES TO BUTTON HER YAP no matter how much we beg and plead. This is what a tornado sounds like when it's miked. She's such a wall-bouncing bundle of enthusiasm that watching her for 10 minutes makes you feel like you just finished a 20-mile training run for the marathon. She's also yammering on and on about stuff that no normal person much cares about: preparing salad, cleaning the counter, picking out shoes, coordinating your eyebrows to your cheekbones. Unfortunately, Ray just landed a 2.8 average household rating and 9 share for her debut on Monday, the highest numbers for any first-run syndie show since "Dr. Phil" launched in September 2002. Such is life when you have Oprah's personal stamp of approval and backing. You can be a hit in spite of yourself. So we'd best get used to Ray's daily verbal assaults on our senses. The ratings just told her, "You go, girl -- and don't you dare shut your mouth!" Oprah, you'll pay for this.
THE MEGAN MULLALLY SHOW -- I honestly wanted Mullally's show to work because she seems such a good egg. So every time she uttered something that made her sound woefully unprepared (which she clearly was) in her Monday debut, I cringed. Things didn't improve much on Tuesday, alas. Megs appears to have made the classic error of believing she can wing it and eschew much in the way of homework and research. But if you sit down with a subject and strive to have an aimless small-talky conversation as you would on a blind date, that's exactly how it appears to somebody watching: like they've crashed a bad first date where the couple has nothing in common. And if your show is a daily series of lousy dates, you don't remain on the air very long. Mullally is sweet and endearing and funny and, sadly, entirely clueless in this venue. Her 1.2 rating/4 share metered market average for Monday is nothing special, boding poorly for her talk show's continued existence beyond, say, two weeks from Friday.
THE GREG BEHRENDT SHOW -- Yeah, that's what I want to do if I'm in a lousy marriage or a cruddy relationship or I'm having trouble getting over a bad breakup: I wanna go on national television and stand there like a twit while a smug, snarky, recovering stand-up comedian makes fun of me. Where do I sign up for that? No big shocker that Behrendt is bombing out rapidly (a microscopic 0.7 rating/2 share average last week during his debut). The co-author of the keep-it-real bestseller "He's Just Not That Into You" and writer's consultant on "Sex and the City" should have seen this coming. He has no actual credentials for telling people how to run their relationships other than a sharp, wise-ass tongue. He's not dispensing tough love or brutal honesty but self-satisfied smarm. The public isn't going to flock to that five days a week, or even five minutes. Bye bye, Greggy. They're just not that into you.
THE DR. KEITH ABLOW SHOW -- All right, so I like this guy. I really, really like him. He's kinder and gentler than Dr. Phil (though this of course isn't really saying much, since most crocodiles are as well). Ablow also displays a genuinely caring/concerned dynamic that helps to mitigate his lame-O name. He listens -- really LISTENS -- to his guests and seems to come closer to dispensing actual therapy on-air than nearly all media shrinks who have come before. But in his kickoff week he averaged a mere 1.0 rating and 3 percent share of the audience, which ain't good. This could stem in part from the fact that as kind and connecting as Ablow is, there is also this gnawing predilection for boredom. He isn't the most compelling force on earth even if he's going out of his way to be America's nurturer-in-chief. What you want from a therapist is the showmanship of Dr. Phil with the humanity of Dr. Keith. Perhaps I've just described Jerry Springer.
UPDATE: "Rachael Ray Show" ratings jumped on Tuesday to 2.9 from 2.8 the day before, while those for "Megan Mullally" slipped to 0.9 from 1.2. It's the end of the world as we know it.